Guide

Payment processors compared: Stripe vs. Authorize.net vs. PayPal vs. Square

What each payment processor charges, the pros and cons of each for dues, event registration and sponsorships, and how to cut what you pay.

By Mike Andersen · Updated October 2026

For most associations and chambers, the choice comes down to four names: Stripe, Authorize.net, PayPal and Square. On standard online card payments their rates are close, around 3% plus a fixed fee per payment. What separates them is monthly fees, how they handle bank transfers for large payments like dues and sponsorships, and how well they connect to your website. All rates below are from each company’s own pricing page, checked in October 2026.

Mike Andersen, who builds every Purple Pushpin site, has collected dues, registrations and sponsorships through several of these processors. One thing up front: Purple Pushpin is built on Stripe, so read the comparison with that in mind.

The quick comparison

StripeAuthorize.netPayPalSquare
Monthly feeNone$25NoneNone on the free plan
Online card payment2.9% + 30¢2.9% + 30¢ (all-in-one plan)2.99% + 49¢ (card), 3.49% + 49¢ (PayPal Checkout)3.3% + 30¢ (online and invoices)
Bank payment (ACH)0.8%, capped at $50.75% (eCheck, $10 monthly minimum)Not listed for standard checkout1%, $1 minimum (invoices)
Nonprofit rateDiscount for donation-heavy charitiesNone listed1.99% + 49¢ for confirmed charitiesNone listed
Dispute fee$15$25 (eCheck)$20None listed

What a single payment actually costs

PaymentStripe cardStripe ACHPayPal CheckoutSquare online
$150 event registration$4.65$1.20$5.73$5.25
$400 annual dues$11.90$3.20$14.45$13.50
$2,500 sponsorship$72.80$5.00$87.74$82.80

The biggest saving isn’t switching processors. It’s getting large payments like sponsorships and corporate dues paid by bank transfer instead of card.

Stripe

  • Pros: no monthly fee, bank payments capped at $5, clean receipts, strong fraud tools, and it connects to almost every modern website and membership platform.
  • Cons: support is mostly online, and extra fees apply for international cards (1.5%), currency conversion (1%) and cards typed in by hand (0.5%).
  • Best for: organizations taking payments on their own website.

Authorize.net

Authorize.net is a payment gateway, the piece that passes card details from your website to the bank. You can use it with its own merchant account (the all-in-one plan) or with a merchant account you already have through your bank.

  • Pros: long track record, works with an existing bank merchant account, and if your bank gives you negotiated rates the gateway-only plan adds just 10¢ per transaction plus a 10¢ daily batch fee.
  • Cons: $25 a month whether you take payments or not, often two relationships to manage (gateway and bank), and an older interface.
  • Best for: organizations already set up with a bank merchant account, or processing enough volume to negotiate rates.

PayPal

  • Pros: people recognize and trust the button, and confirmed charities get a lower rate.
  • Cons: the highest standard rates of the four, a 49¢ fixed fee, and payers may leave your site to finish.
  • Best for: donation-heavy charities that qualify for the charity rate, or as a second option at checkout.

Square

  • Pros: excellent for in-person payments (2.6% + 15¢ tapped or swiped), easy card readers, simple invoices.
  • Cons: the online and invoice rate of 3.3% + 30¢ is higher than Stripe’s, and it’s built more for shops than membership websites.
  • Best for: chambers with a visitor center or events where most money changes hands in person.

Ways to pay less, whichever you choose

  • Offer bank payment for dues, sponsorships and anything over a few hundred dollars.
  • Invoice companies and let them pay by ACH.
  • Bill dues annually, so you pay the fixed fee once instead of twelve times.
  • Avoid typing in card numbers by hand. Send a payment link instead.
  • Use a clear statement descriptor so members recognize the charge and don’t dispute it.
  • Be careful passing fees on. Some states restrict credit card surcharges, and card network rules don’t allow surcharges on debit cards. Check before you add one.

Frequently asked questions

Is Stripe or Authorize.net better for a nonprofit?

For most small organizations taking payments on their website, Stripe costs less because it has no monthly fee. Authorize.net makes sense if you already have a bank merchant account with good rates.

What is the cheapest way for an association to accept payments?

Bank transfers (ACH) for larger payments, and a no-monthly-fee card processor for everything else.

Do payment processors give nonprofits a discount?

Some do, but usually only for charitable donations. See our guide to Stripe for nonprofits for why dues and tickets usually don’t qualify.

What is the difference between a payment gateway and a payment processor?

A gateway securely passes card details from your website. A processor and merchant account move the money. Stripe, PayPal and Square bundle all of it; Authorize.net can be used either way.

Where Purple Pushpin fits

Purple Pushpin uses Stripe, connected to your organization’s own Stripe account. Payments go straight to you, Purple Pushpin never holds your money, and it doesn’t add a fee of its own on top of Stripe’s.

See it for yourself

Click around a real one.

The Purple Pushpin demo is a complete fictional chamber and association. Log in to the admin side your board would use, no sales call needed.

Try the demo See pricing