How to spot phishing: a 10-minute briefing for volunteer boards
The warning signs, the fake messages most often sent to association and chamber boards, and what to do when someone clicks.
By Mike Andersen · Updated October 2026
Phishing is a fake message, usually email but also texts and calls, designed to get you to click a link, sign in on a fake page, open an attachment or send money. Most break-ins at small organizations start this way. You don’t need a security team to defend against it. You need everyone on the board to know a handful of warning signs, and to feel comfortable saying “this looks off” before they click.
Mike Andersen, who builds every Purple Pushpin site, works with volunteer boards that change every year or two. This is the briefing he’d give at the first meeting of each new board.
The warning signs
- Urgency or secrecy. “Today,” “immediately,” “don’t mention this to anyone.”
- A sender address that doesn’t match. The name says your president; the address is a random Gmail account.
- A link that goes somewhere unexpected. Hover over it, or press and hold on a phone, to see the real address before you click.
- A sign-in page you reached from an email. If you need to sign in to Microsoft, Google, your bank or Stripe, go there directly instead.
- Unexpected attachments, especially invoices, “voicemails,” “scanned documents” or zipped files.
- Requests for money, gift cards, codes or passwords.
- Something that’s slightly wrong: an odd greeting, a logo that looks off, a domain one letter different from the real one.
Fakes boards often see
| The fake | What it wants |
|---|---|
| “A document has been shared with you” | Your email password, on a fake sign-in page |
| “Your mailbox is full” or “your password expires today” | Your email password |
| “Please sign this agreement” | A click on a fake e-signature link |
| “Your domain is expiring” | A payment, or your registrar login |
| “Updated invoice attached” | A payment to the wrong account, or an infected file |
| A text from “the president” asking for a favor | Gift cards |
| A QR code on a flyer or email | A visit to a fake sign-in or payment page |
If you’re not sure
- Don’t click, don’t reply.
- Check another way. Call the person, or go to the website directly by typing its address.
- Ask someone. Forward it to whoever handles your website or email and ask.
- Report it using your email’s “report phishing” button.
If someone already clicked
- Don’t be embarrassed. Say so right away. Minutes matter more than blame.
- If they entered a password, change it immediately from a trusted device, and anywhere else it was used.
- Sign out of all sessions and turn on two-step verification if it wasn’t on.
- Check the mailbox for new forwarding rules or filters the attacker may have added.
- If money or member data might be involved, follow our data breach response plan.
Make it a habit, not a lecture
- Ten minutes at the first meeting after elections.
- A standing rule: any request for money or codes gets a phone call.
- Thank people who report suspicious messages, even when they turn out to be real.
- Turn on two-step verification everywhere. It stops most stolen passwords from working.
Frequently asked questions
What is phishing?
A fake message designed to trick you into clicking a link, entering a password, opening a file or sending money.
How can you tell if an email is phishing?
Check the sender’s real address, hover over links before clicking, and be suspicious of urgency, unexpected attachments and requests for money or passwords.
What should I do if I clicked a phishing link?
Tell someone right away, change your password from a trusted device, sign out of all sessions and turn on two-step verification.
Does two-step verification stop phishing?
It stops most stolen passwords from being enough on their own. The strongest forms, passkeys and security keys, also resist fake sign-in pages.
Where Purple Pushpin fits
Purple Pushpin gives each board member their own login, so one person’s mistake doesn’t expose a shared password, and access can be removed for one person without changing everyone else’s. More in what never to share.
See it for yourself
Click around a real one.
The Purple Pushpin demo is a complete fictional chamber and association. Log in to the admin side your board would use, no sales call needed.